A recent IMF report outlining the economic outlook of MENA states painted a positive but cautious portrait of North African states after the Arab Spring, with both potential and obstacles linked to the fortunes of the region’s energy sector.
From Rabat to Cairo, the post-Arab Spring region will depend heavily on energy use and production plans to get them through the next year, according to the IMF’s biannual Regional Economic Outlook Update for the Middle East and Central Asia report.
The Producers
Unsurprisingly, the IMF report painted a rosier picture for oil and gas exporting states in the region, though they were quick to add that significant obstacles to growth and economic stability remained, mostly in the form of political uncertainties, periphery conflicts and the lingering impact of the European debt crisis.
In the case of countries like Algeria, Spain’s second recession in four years does little to help the government’s ability to keep natural gas revenues in line with public spending needed to keep an increasingly agitated population happy. For government officials in Algiers, oil revenues would need to stay at least above $100 a barrel to cover the expense of the country’s subsidy programs and state spending, according to a Financial Times report.
Instead of reducing government support systems, Algeria has moved to expand them with this week’s announcement that they would introduce legislation outlining new incentive programs for the country’s burgeoning shale industry. Pointing to projects in the US and Poland, Algeria have outlined a plan to increase revenue and expand domestic production through tax incentives and a pledge on the part of the state-backed firm Sonatrach to invest up to $80 billion over five years, with 60 percent going towards shale exploration and production, according to a Bloomberg report.
Shared Concerns
“Oil-importing, especially Arab Spring, countries will need to set out on their own paths toward economic modernization and transformation,” read the report. “But they will also need to rely on financial assistance and technical and policy advice from the international community to support homegrown reform agendas. “
Ensuring such outside funding has emerged as the most glaring challenge for both importing and exporting countries due to lingering instability and its impact on
foreign investment and other financial support coming from international institutions. Without political stability across a region heavy with new governments, investors and financing agencies remain cautious, slowing the process of infrastructure recovery in Libya. According to a regional energy analyst at CIDOB, a Barcelona-based foreign policy think tank, the lingering uncertainty about North Africa has forced a “wait and see” approach on the part of European and US investors, as well as funding institutions.
In Egypt, a lack of political consensus has hindered the new government’s ability to ensure a $3.2 billion development loan from the IMF and threatened much largr potential agreements from Gulf state funds. For their part, the IMF cited a lack of a clear direction as reason for pause. This political instability has been most evident in Libya as interest from much needed foreign oil and gas partners is being tested by an interim government seen as dragging its feet on providing opportunities and access to Africa’s second largest proven reserves.
Unfortunately, that stability is not restricted to whether political coalitions can organize in time or ensure safe and effective elections. Across the region, questions about violence and safety have plagued governments, making the prospect of attracting needed foreign investment all the more difficult. Most recently, tension between Sudan and the newly autonomous Southern Sudan boiled over into violence as a result of conflicting claims about oil reserves. The potential for the Sudanese conflict to spread has demanded the diplomatic attention of regional neighbors, including the Egyptian government who sent representatives to help ease tensions.
To the west, the potential threat of the Northern Mali separatist movement spilling over into the Southern Sahara areas of Libya and Algeria have kept officials and investors on edge in those countries.
Seeking Solutions
In the case of Morocco, leaders in Rabat were able to boast one of the North Africa’s only steady increase in per capita income, but pitfalls remain, especially in light of the country’s weak domestic potential and heavy dependence on foreign resources. During a recent conversation with Forbes, Fouad Douiri, Morocco’s newly appointed Minister of Energy, Mines, Water and the Environment said the country will address development and energy issues by targeting renewable projects in favor of shale, offshore or traditional drilling operations. Outlining plans to install more than 2000 MW of solar, wind and hydro power, Douiri said that the government intends to « reduce Morocco’s annual imports of fossil fuels by 2.5 million tons of oil equivalent and to prevent the emissions of 9 million tons of carbon dioxide.”
While confident that they will be able to continue funding such efforts, the Moroccan government face significant fiscal shortfalls thanks to an increase in subsidies and public work jobs offered to calm growing political opposition last year.
Originally Distributed by Newsbase. All Rights Reserved.
Image: Energyboom.com
Egyptian Energy Presses Ahead Despite Criticism
Despite extensive efforts, Egypt has struggled to get their economy back on track in the year since widespread public protests led to the ousting of long-standing president Hosni Mubarak. Political instability and uncertain investors have kept needed international funding at bay, as Cairo works to establish a solid foundation for the country’s first new government after decades of Mubarak leadership. The country’s coveted tourism sector remains weak and despite enormous reported potential, Egypt’s renewable industry has been slow to start as investors and international financing agencies adopt a ‘Wait-and-See’ attitude.
Still, despite the stagnate pace of growth and economic recovery, one sector of the country’s economy has continued to shows signs of life – Egypt’s oil and natural gas producers. According to United States National Public Radio report this week, the country’s General Petroleum Company, the government office charged with making final decisions on exploration and production agreements, has continued to add to the country’s 148 standing partnerships.
The continued rounds of licensing for both on and offshore efforts comes despite strong criticism aimed at how such efforts were carried out under the Mubarak government, with critics leveling complaints at a perceived lack of transparency about pricing and the amount of domestic reserves set aside for exporting.
The continued lack of transparency surrounding the natural gas deals has critics worried that even with Mubarak gone, the Egyptian government may still be allowing the kind of controversial agreements that led to a wave of protest earlier this year. The backlash came soon after an investigation uncovered payment agreements with Israel and Jordan for Egyptian natural gas that assured under-market prices in exchange for benefits for local government officials. While Jordan was quick to work out a renegotiated deal, contested trade agreements with Israel added to existing strain between new political leaders in Cairo and its eastern neighbor. The situation was further complicated by a series of now 14 attacks on natural gas pipelines in the Sinai region of Egypt, halting exports again and again. Energy relations between the two countries showed little sign of improving after Cairo cancelled a 2005 export agreement with Israel, who currently depend on Egypt for 40 percent of their energy needs.
More than just lost revenues, the decision to cancel Egypt’s 20-year deal to supply natural gas to Israel is now resulting in a lawsuit filed by investors in the East Mediterranean Gas for violations of bi-lateral investment treaties, according to a Bloomberg report.
Despite such criticism, the government may have little choice than to support new production deals under the pressure of mounting debt and wavering interest from existing project partners. According to Australia’s The National, the Egyptian government has accrued about $4 billion in debt to international energy firms due in part to large-scale purchases to allow for heavily subsidized domestic sales. This comes despite the country’s own 78 trillion cubic feet of proven natural gas reserves. This debt has recently increased, according to the report, due to late payments as a result of the country’s recent political instability.
Further complicating the situation for the government and local partners, the country’s recent uncertainty and apparent high cost of operating in Egyptian territory has pushed some international firms to reassess their presence there. In November of last year, Royal Dutch Shell handed back an offshore block, stating that the high costs of operating there overshadowed the possible rate of return.
Still, many firms are looking past the country’s current predicament and ahead to a potentially calmer new year, including Houston’s Apache and the UK’s BP, who are hoping to capitalize on a 2010 offshore effort. In fact, it is the government’s willingness to pursue new deals despite the country’s current challenges that has Apache feeling confident about the months ahead.
“Our operation has continued [uninterrupted] and supported by government partners as evidenced by the issuance of new…leases,” Apache President and Chief Operating Officer Rodney Eichler said, according to a Dow Jones report. “We are optimistic for Apache’s future in Egypt.”
Given the financial limitations of the country’s current government, anything more than new licenses may be too much to hope for. Burdened by significant budget shortfalls, the Egyptian government will be unlikely to consider any price renegotiations with existing production partners, regardless of the additional risks now associated with operating in the country.
However, regardless of either company’s intentions or interests, existing deals could soon come under scrutiny should critics chose to build on the investigation that put a spotlight on the Israeli and Jordanian deals.
“Some terms that are now in question are part of the 2010 deal with BP for the extraction of deepwater Mediterranean gas,” reported NPR. “While many details of the deal have not been made public, it has many critics.”
A similar threat of agreement reviews has foreign partners on edge in Libya, where the country’s transitional government has pledged to take a closer look at those oil and gas agreements completed under Gadaffi.
Originally Published at Newsbase’s Afroil Report. All Rights Reserved.
Image: Modern Egypt.info